As a result of the study of the discipline, the applicant of higher education of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy must be able to demonstrate the following learning outcomes:
know:
1. In-depth knowledge of methodological support for the unity of judicial practice in the application of administrative, criminal and criminal procedural law.
2. In-depth knowledge of legal support for Ukraine's accession to a single European scientific and innovative space.
•

be able:
1. To apply the acquired knowledge from different subject areas of law to formulate and justify new theoretical provisions and practical recommendations in a specific field of research.
2. Apply modern methods of analysis to establish the unity of human rights, democracy and the rule of law as fundamental values of the modern world.
3. Ability to plan and conduct comparative legal studies, identify current trends and trends in the legal system of Ukraine.
4. Apply knowledge of the laws of the relationship between national and international law.
5. Conduct scientific discussions and discussions in the appropriate professional level in Ukrainian and English, present the results of scientific research in oral and written form, organize and conduct training sessions.

Criminal Law
Basics of criminal qualification
Topical issues of theory and practice in the field of criminal law

Curriculum "Criminal Law Research Workshop" - a special legal discipline that provides a compulsory study that studies the law, practice and science of crime and punishment in the system of legal disciplines and belongs to the fundamental and specialized . It envisages the study of a complex of criminal law institutes and theoretical provisions and a considerable array of both national and international legal acts, resolutions of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of Ukraine. Topical issues of theory and practice in the field of criminal law - one of the most important and basic disciplines, taught at the National University "Lviv Polytechnic". A thorough knowledge of our country's criminal law is a prerequisite for successful work in law enforcement or practicing law. Drawing on prior knowledge of the major legal institutions, categories and concepts of criminal law, graduate students must not only understand but also analyze the problematic issues of the course "Criminal Law Research Workshop", as well as offer their substantiated proposals in criminal law legislation. Assistance in this work should be materials of scientific-practical conferences, speeches of practitioners of law-enforcement bodies, development and scientific works of scientists of academy, and also works of other leading researchers both domestic and foreign. Criminal law is structurally divided into two closely related parts - the General and the Special. The General Part contains rules defining the tasks, principles and basic institutions of criminal law. The special part consists of a set of norms, which contain the basic features of specific acts that are recognized as a crime, and set certain types and the degree of punishment for their commission.

1. Antipov VV Circumstances Excluding the Use of Criminal Punishment: Monograph / V.V. Antipov, VI Antipodes. - K .: Attica, 2004. - 208 p
2. Antonov AD Principles of criminalization of socially dangerous acts in criminal law / AD. Antonov // MSU Bulletin. Avg. 11. Right. - 2000. - № 4. - P. 79-90.
3. Antonyuk NO Criminal liability for damage to property by fraud or abuse of trust: Monograph. - Lviv, PAIS, 2008. - 216 p.
4. Bagri-Shakhmatov LV Social and legal problems of criminal responsibility and forms of its implementation. - O.: Legal Literature, 2000. - 412 p.
5. Bazhanov MI Multiplicity of criminal offenses under the criminal law of Ukraine / M.I. Bazhanov. - Kharkiv: Law, 2000. - 128 p.
6. Baulin YV Criminal Release: Monograph. - K .: Attica, 2004. - 296 p.
7. Bachinin VA The philosophy of crime and punishment. - Kharkov, Folio, 1999. - 607 p.
8. Beckaria C. On crime and punishment. - M .: Stealth, 1995. - 303 p.
9. Knizhenko OO Sanctions in criminal law: monograph / OO. Knizhenko. - Kharkiv: NikaNova, 2011. - 336 p.
10. Krivochenko LM Classification of crimes by severity in the Criminal code of Ukraine: monograph / L.M. Krivochenko. - K .: Yurinkom Inter, 2010. - 120 p.
11. Trubnikov VM Man, Science and the Laws of Development in a New Civil Society // From Civil Society to the Rule of Law: Abstracts of the YIU International Scientific and Practical Conference. - Х .: KhNU named after VN Karazin, 2009. - 455 p.
12. Trubnikov VM Some Conceptual Directions for Improving the Criminal and Criminal Enforcement Law of Ukraine // Bulletin of Kharkiv. nat. Univ. named after VN Karazin. No. 872. Series: Right. Collection of scientific works. Issue № 6. - Х .: KhNU named after VN Karazin, 2009. - 305 p.
13. Trubnikov VM Criminal law as an instrument of justice // From civil society to the rule of law: Abstracts In International Scientific and Practical Conference. - Kharkov: VN KhNU. Karazin, 2010. - 400 p.
14. Trubnikov VM Free will or fate? // From Civil Society - to the Legal Derivative: Theory and Practice of Crime Prevention: UI International Scientific and Practical Conference, April 15, 2011, Kharkiv: Collection of Abstracts. - Kharkov: VN KhNU. Karazin, 2011. - 246 p.
15. Trubnikov VM System of measures of criminal-legal influence instead of system of punishments // Bulletin of Khark. nat. Univ. named after VN Karazin. No. 945. Series: Right. Collection of scientific works. - Х .: KhNU named after VN Karazin, 2011. - 356 p.
16. Fesenko EV The object of the crime from the perspective of the theory of values, as well as opponents of this concept / Е.В. Fesenko // Lawyer. - 2003. - № 6. - P. 9.
17. Zinchenko I. Qualification of crimes in their multiplicity and competition of criminal law norms. Kharkiv: Right, 2017. 114 p.
18. Ivanov A. Qualification of crime as a mandatory element of establishing objective truth. Crime Investigation: Problems and Solutions: Sat. scientific-practical tr. M., 2013. Issue. 1, pp. 71-75.
19. Orlovsky R. Differentiation of criminal liability in complicity. Issues of Combating Crime: Coll. of sciences. Kharkiv Ave., Law, 2013. Vol. 26. P. 53-63.
20. Orlovsky R. Criminal liability for unsuccessful complicity. Herald
21. Sozansky T. Qualification of crime. Lviv: LuVS, 2012. 240 p.
22. Tatsy V. The object and object of the crime in criminal law. Kharkiv: Law, 2016. 256 p.
23. Silent V. Crime, its types and stages. Kyiv: Rays, 2007. 40 p.
24. Us O. Qualification of crimes: essence and concept. Bulletin of Kharkiv National University. V. Karazin. №1106. Right series. 2014. Vol. 17. P. 171-175.
25. Us O. Criminal liability for incitement to crime. Kharkiv: FOP Publishing House Vapnyarchuk NM, 2007. 264 p.
26. Us O. Criminal legal assessment of the act on the grounds of the object of the crime. Scientific Bulletin of Uzhgorod National University. Right series. 2016. Vyp. 41, Vol. 2, pp. 139-144.
27. Us O. Criteria for classifications and types of criminal qualification. Scientific Bulletin of Kherson State University. Legal Sciences Series. 2015. Vol. 5. P. 15-19.
28. Shevchenko E. Crimes with derivative consequences. Kharkiv: Publishing House SPD-FO Vapnyarchuk NM, 2005. 216 p.
29. Yaremko G. Blanket Dispositions in Articles of the Particular Part of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. Lviv: LDUVS, 2011. 432 p.

Methods of diagnostics of educational success, forms of measurement of the level of mastering of knowledge in the discipline are:
- oral interview at practical (seminar) classes;
- speech at practical (seminar) sessions (with abstract, report, discussion etc.);
- testing of students' knowledge on the relevant topic of the lecture course;
- written test work (answers to the questions of the lecture course, solving practical problems (cases), test problems, etc.);
- protection of individual written task;
- homework assignment,
- form of final control: credit.


Criteria for evaluating postgraduate learning outcomes

Current success is 40
Research tasks - 60
The final score is 100